Objective Redact Alternative Without the Procurement Cycle
The 20-second verdictEverything that decides this switch, in one place
- RedactProof: 60+ PII types found automatically, working the same day. Jump to head-to-head
- Objective finds only what its searches and templates are set up to find. Jump to detection
- It reaches a desk via quote-based sales and an IT-managed rollout. Jump to speed
- Governance reports are internal: the requester can't verify the file. Jump to verification
- Our verdict, including where the FOI incumbent is still the right choice. Jump to verdict
Head to head
The Objective Redact vs RedactProof snapshot
What each tool is, in one card each.
The government incumbent
FOI-grade desktop redaction, sold by quote
- One-click FOI exemption codes
- Local desktop processing, Office add-ins
- Detection limited to configured patterns
- Quote-priced, IT-deployed
- No requester-side verification
The self-serve specialist
Browser redaction, priced on the website
- 60+ PII types found automatically
- Files never leave the browser
- Published pricing, start today
- Requester-verifiable certificates and audit trail
- Surge and temp staff covered instantly
At a glance
The whole comparison in one table
The five facts that decide most switches.
| Feature | Objective Redact | RedactProof |
|---|---|---|
| Automatic detection | Search Search-driven, rule-based | Included 60+ PII types, entirely in-browser |
| No file upload | On-device Desktop-local; working copy created | Yes The file never leaves your browser |
| Document limits | Quote Enterprise quote-based | Unlimited Flat rate on paid plans |
| Export verification | Report Governance report, not recipient-verifiable | Included Ed25519 certificate + QR, optional per export |
| Platforms | Desktop Desktop app + Office add-ins | Any browser Mac, Windows, Linux, nothing to install |
The detail
Three differences that decide it
Where your file goes, what you pay, and what the recipient can prove.
Detection Beyond the Patterns You Configure
Objective Redact finds what its searches, regular expressions and templates are set up to find, which works well for structured identifiers in familiar document layouts. FOI and SAR bundles are rarely that tidy. RedactProof's automatic detection surfaces 60+ PII types, including the names, addresses and free-text identifiers that pattern rules miss, and the caseworker approves each suggestion before export.
Working Today, Priced on the Website
Objective Redact reaches a desk through quote-based sales and an IT-managed desktop rollout. That suits a large agency standardising for years; it is slow for a records team that needs capacity this week. RedactProof's pricing is published, the trial is immediate, and the tool runs in the browser already on every machine, including for temporary staff and surge workloads. Upload nothing, start a redaction now: the free trial document needs no procurement approval, no IT ticket, and no sales call.
Verification the Requester Can Check
Objective Redact's governance reports document the redaction internally, which auditors value. RedactProof extends the evidence to the other side: every export on Pro carries an Ed25519 signature and QR code, so a requester, tribunal or scrutiny body can independently confirm the disclosed file is exactly what was exported. Internal reporting and external proof are different assurances, and disclosure needs both.
Who Actually Buys Objective Redact
Objective Redact sits inside a wider records and information management suite from an ASX-listed vendor with a long history selling into UK and Australian public sector. The buyers are usually FOI teams, information governance units, and records offices at councils, NHS trusts, and central government departments that already run Objective's broader platform for case and document management. If your organisation is standardising a records function across hundreds of seats over a multi-year contract, this is familiar territory: a formal vendor relationship, a support desk, and Office add-ins that plug into workflows caseworkers already use.
That profile matters because it shapes everything else about the product: the sales motion, the deployment model, and the pace at which a new team can actually start redacting.
How the Redaction Itself Works
Objective Redact's detection is rule-driven rather than automatic. A caseworker sets up search-and-redact rules for structured identifiers, writes regular expressions, applies templates for fields that sit in the same place on every form, and runs OCR against scanned pages. When those rules match the document in front of you, the tool is fast and precise. When the document is a scanned witness statement, a chain of emails, or a case file with names and addresses scattered through free text, the tool only catches what the configured rule was written to catch.
That is a real strength for the document types it was built for. Structured tax file references, fixed-position case numbers, anything that lives at a predictable coordinate on a predictable form: pattern rules handle that reliably, arguably more predictably than a model would. Where it struggles is the unstructured middle of most disclosure bundles: correspondence, notes, attachments, the parts of an FOI or SAR response that were never designed to be machine-readable in the first place. Nothing in what Objective publishes suggests the product tries to close that gap with automatic detection; it is a search-and-pattern tool, and it does that job on its own terms.
Where the Document Sits While You Work
On data handling, Objective Redact is genuinely local: it is a desktop application, processing happens on the machine it is installed on, and it creates a working copy rather than touching the original. For a records team worried about a document leaving the building during redaction, that is a legitimate answer, and it is one reason the product has stayed credible with public-sector procurement for as long as it has.
The friction is upstream of the redaction step. Getting the tool onto a caseworker's machine means an IT-managed rollout: packaging, a deployment cycle, add-ins registered against Word, PowerPoint and Excel. For a records team that needs to redact a live FOI request or a subject access request this week, that lead time is the practical obstacle, not the processing model. Under UK GDPR and FOIA, the clock on a SAR or an FOI response starts the day the request lands, and a procurement and IT rollout cycle does not pause for it.
How the Same Job Looks in RedactProof
When we walk a caseworker through RedactProof, the difference shows up before the redaction step. There is no install: the document opens in the browser and never leaves it, so a temporary member of staff covering a backlog can start on their own laptop the same morning. Automatic detection then surfaces candidates across 60+ PII types, names and free-text identifiers included, and the caseworker reviews and approves each one before anything is touched. Nothing exports on the strength of the detection alone.
60+
PII types RedactProof surfaces automatically. Objective Redact redacts the patterns a caseworker configures, so the identifier outside the ruleset is the one that slips through.
What actually leaves the browser is a pixel-burned file: the flagged regions are removed from the underlying image and text data, not layered over with a black box that a careless copy-paste can undo. On Pro, every export also carries an Ed25519-signed certificate with a QR code, so the recipient, a requester, a tribunal, a scrutiny committee, can check independently that the file they received matches what was signed at export, without needing an account of their own or a call back to your records team. Objective's governance reports are built for internal audit trails; RedactProof extends that further, so the other side of the disclosure can run their own check too.
The Honest Answer
If your organisation has already standardised on Objective's platform, needs one-click statutory exemption codes wired into an established FOI workflow, and has the IT and procurement capacity to run a formal desktop rollout, Objective Redact remains a sound, specialist choice built for exactly that context.
For a records or legal team that needs to start redacting today, without a procurement cycle, and wants automatic detection plus a certificate the recipient can verify on their own, RedactProof is built for that gap.
The verdict
Built for the same duty. Delivered at very different speeds.
- Objective Redact means an IT-managed rollout and a procurement cycle. RedactProof is working the same day: it runs in the browser, with published pricing and no framework purchase.
- Its detection follows the patterns you configure; ours flags 60+ types of personal data automatically, so a stray identifier outside the pattern set is still caught.
- Its governance report documents the redaction internally. RedactProof extends the proof outward: every disclosure can carry a certificate the requester verifies for themselves.
Where Objective Redact Has the Edge
Its FOI pedigree is real: one-click exemption codes aligned to FOI and privacy legislation, governance reporting, deep Office integration, and an ASX-listed vendor with decades of government deployments, typically procured via UK public-sector frameworks such as G-Cloud. An agency that needs statutory exemption workflows, a formal support contract and an established vendor relationship is squarely in Objective's territory.
Weighing more options than just Objective Redact? See how all 18 redaction tools compare side by side.
Our security evidence
Cloud redaction tools are audited on how they handle your uploaded documents. RedactProof takes that question away at the source: documents are processed in your browser and never uploaded, so there is no server-side copy to breach and no data processor relationship to audit.
RedactProof (operated by Popsall Ltd) is Cyber Essentials certified (the UK government-backed NCSC/IASME scheme), registered with the ICO (ZC164232), and carries professional indemnity and cyber insurance. The full architecture is documented on our security page.
What it costs
Every price, before you sign up
Public sector buys by order form. No quotes, no sales calls, prices published all year round. · Compare Core vs Pro in detail
Common questions
What people ask when comparing Objective Redact and RedactProof.
How much does Objective Redact cost?
Objective does not publish pricing; it is sold on a quote basis, with UK public-sector buyers typically procuring through frameworks such as G-Cloud. Figures on third-party listing sites are inconsistent and unverified, so treat them cautiously. RedactProof publishes its pricing: a free trial document, Flex Packs from $25, an annual Core licence and per-seat Pro pricing.
Does Objective Redact detect PII automatically?
Its detection is search-driven: search-and-redact for identifiers such as tax file and credit card numbers, regular expressions, templates for fixed-position fields, and OCR for scanned pages. It finds what those rules describe. RedactProof's automatic detection covers 60+ PII types without pre-configured patterns, which matters most in unstructured correspondence and case files.
Is Objective Redact cloud-based?
No. It is a desktop application that processes documents locally, creating a working copy and leaving the original unchanged. RedactProof is also local-first: documents are processed in the browser and never uploaded, with the same no-upload guarantee but no desktop install, IT rollout, or procurement step.
Why choose RedactProof over Objective Redact?
Speed to value and detection depth. RedactProof works in the browser today with published pricing and no procurement cycle, detects 60+ PII types automatically rather than by configured pattern, and gives every export on Pro a certificate the requester can verify. If your organisation needs statutory FOI exemption-code workflows and a formal enterprise vendor relationship, Objective Redact remains the specialist incumbent for that. Otherwise, try RedactProof free on one document today, no procurement, no install, no card.
Redaction is the whole product here
Load a document in your browser and see what 60+ PII types detected locally looks like. One document free.
Try RedactProof freeObjective Redact is a product of Objective Corporation Limited. All product names, trademarks and registered trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Product details were checked in August 2026 against objective.com; Objective does not publish pricing.